Charles Meltonis all that and a bag of chips — or Gushers!

Ina fun segmentfor hisdigital cover story with PEOPLE, the 33-year-oldMay Decemberactor digs through a box of items from the ’90s and Y2K area, to “see if it triggers any nostalgia” for him.

First up are the aforementioned Gushers, a ’90s-kid staple that features fruit snacks with a sweet, juicy center. “Oh wow,” Melton says, popping some in his mouth. “I used to put these in the freezer.”

Next up? A collection of books from theGoosebumpsseries, which Melton says he “loved” growing up. Among the titles included areThe Beast from the East,Ghost CampandAttack of the Jack-O'-Lanterns, which were all released in 1996 circa theR.L. Stinebooks' heyday.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.

Charles Melton holding R.L. Stine’sGoosebumpsseries bookThe Beast from the East(1996).

See Charles Melton Adorably React to ’90s Stuff

Plucking aBlockbuster Videomembership card from the box next, the actor reveals he used to make it a Blockbuster night often, having gone to thenow-almost-extinct video store"a lot" as a kid instead of the library.

One movie that’s close to his heart?A Knight’s Tale, as he proves when he pulls out a VHS copy of the 2001 medieval action-comedy romance starring the lateHeath Ledger.

“When I put this movie on, it always cheers me up. Love this film,” Melton raves, adding with a smile, “I watched this, like, a week ago.”

Charles Melton with a VHS copy ofA Knight’s Tale(2001).

See Charles Melton Adorably React to ’90s Stuff

Melton also explores a Game Boy Color, Mr. Sketch Scented Markers (a ’90s classroom must-have), a portable CD player — and of course, a vintageArchiecomic from the ’90s.

“What an iconic show to be a part of,” Melton says. “Therelationships that I built filming that show, the people that I worked with — it informed so many things that I’ve learned as an actor and really just changed my life. Some of my best friends are on that show.”

“It’s a bittersweet thing,” he adds, joking in addition with a laugh, “Those tears will not come today in this interview.”

source: people.com