Photo: Todd Owyoung/NBC via Getty, Amy Sussman/Getty

Chip Joanna Gaines, Taylor Swift

Chip and Joanna Gainesshared a special moment withTaylor Swift. . . they think.

TheFixer Upper: Welcome Homestars told the story onThe Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallonof how they attended the Time100 event in 2019 and saw stars like Martha Stewart and Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, but were ultimately shocked when they shared a moment with the “Anti-Hero” singer.

“Taylor swiftrolls in, she kind of catches eye contact with, I thought, me, but Jo swears to this day it was her, and she goes like this to us,” Chip, 48, tells hostJimmy Fallon, making a heart symbol with his hands.

“But we both thought it was for sure someone behind us,” Joanna, 44, says, noting that she and her husband both looked over their shoulder to see who Swift was looking at, because they didn’t believe it was them.

“We’re looking over our shoulders,” Chip says, “Like Idiots,” Joanna adds.

Chip then teases that Swift may have made the gesture to Fallon, since he was sitting in the front row ahead of them, saying, “it was one of us three for sure.”

Chip adds, “It made our day! We were thrilled. We were smitten.”

The Magnolia Network co-founder is clearly a Swiftie as he tells Fallon about one of the singer’s traditions he admires. “She sends gift baskets whenever she releases one of her albums,” he says. “So, we’re like hugeTaylor Swiftfans.”

Related Video:Joanna Gaines on How She’s Changed as a Mom: ‘I Always Thought I Should Have the Answers’

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The network’s ever-expanding slate of shows also includesFixer Upper: The Castle,Magnolia Table withJoanna Gaines, Restoration Road with Clint Harp,andMaine Cabin Masters.

source: people.com