Chrishell Stauseis sharing her side of a blind date gone wrong on the latest season ofSelling Sunset.

Stause, 40, was set up with Robert Drenk during episode 5 on season 4 of theNetflixhit — but their date turned awkward when Drenk picked up Stause and carried her away while she and her costars were dancing together on a yacht.

Drenk posted anInstagramWednesday promising to show “what really went down” onSelling Sunset, writing, “I was setup [sic] on a blind date back in June that was filmed forSelling Sunsetseason 4. My friends [Tarek El Moussa] and [Heather Rae Young] had spoke with [Chrishell Stause] and she was interested in going on a date. I guessSelling Sunsetfilm crew overheard and wanted it for the show.”

After Drenk tagged her in the post, Stause (who is currently dating her costarJason Oppenheim) requested that he stop tagging her online in a lengthy comment, and shared her take on their blind date, which she claimed took place while she was “100% single.”

Amy Sussman/Getty

47th Annual People’s Choice Awards - Arrivals

“I would have understood if you were nervous and acted differently because of that,” Stause wrote, adding, “I originally enjoyed meeting you until I started to see things I didn’t vibe with. But picking me up & then not getting up to let me out was not great.”

Replying to her response, Drenk wrote that he was “defending [his] position,” and accused Stause of “trying to make it seem like I threw off bad vibes.” He added that theSelling Sunsetstar revealed that she had “hooked up” with Oppenheim five days after filming their blind date.

“It’s obvious my attempt to sweep you off your feet could not be well received 😂,” Drenk wrote. “I don’t think you’re sincere or honest and I don’t appreciate you trying to make me look like someone I’m not.”

The exchange comes after Stause and Drenk got into another spat about the blind date onTwitterearlier this month. At the time, Drenk claimed, “the real reason the date went sideways from the second I showed up” was because Oppenheim was on the boat. “I guess hiding your man from the man that came to a blind date makes for lots of cringe,” hetweeted.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Stause replied, “Oh hi Robert! Jason was not my boyfriend here. In fact that step came much later. But if thinking that makes you feel better about your behavior, I get it,” to which Drenk wrote back, “That’s not what the internet is saying.”

The reality star didn’t budge, urging Drenk to “take the L” and telling him, “You never pick up a woman w/o permission & if she wants to leave, refusing to get up to let me out was ridiculous.” She admitted, “Jason& [sic] I did hook up in Vegas that weekend actually after he had put it out there but I wasn’t sure. Thank you for showing me what I did NOT want.”

From there, Drenk claimed Stause was “rude from the first second I stepped on the boat,” adding, “If that’s how you meet men on dates it explains a lot and trust me I took the W.”

Though the disputed date took a turn for the worse, Stause has since found love with Oppenheim, whom she’sbeen datingsince this summer. The pair went public with their romance in July, and the Oppenheim Group president and ownerconfirmedthe news to PEOPLE.

“Chrishell and I became close friends and it has developed into an amazing relationship,” he said at the time, adding, “I care about her deeply and we are very happy together.”

source: people.com